Federal Court Puts the Brakes on White House Plan to Cap New CDLs

by TRUCKERS VA
(UNITED STATES)

Introduction – No More Game of “Who Gets a CDL?” (For Now)

If you’ve been wondering when the next regulatory curveball would hit the trucking world — well, here it is. A federal appeals court has just put a pause on a rule by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) that would have reined in the issuance of new commercial driver’s licenses (CDLs) to non‑domiciled applicants.
DC Velocity
+1

In practical terms: states can continue issuing and renewing CDLs for drivers who don’t have permanent residence in that state — at least until the legal battle is resolved.
Yahoo
+1

Let’s dig in. What happened, why it matters, the viewpoints you won’t always hear, and what this means for the road ahead.

The Rule & The Legal Stop Sign

Here’s a quick rundown of the proposed rule:

FMCSA published an interim final rule (IFR) tightening eligibility for non‑domiciled CDLs and commercial learner’s permits.
Trucksafe
+1

The rule would restrict states from issuing a CDL to someone who doesn’t have a residence or domicile in that state, unless they’re in specific visa categories like H‑2A, H‑2B or E‑2.
Trucksafe
+1

The stated goal: restore integrity in CDL issuance, reduce safety risks tied to drivers whose foreign driving histories may not be verifiable.
FreightWaves
+1

Then the court:

On November 10, 2025, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit issued a temporary stay of the IFR “pending further order of the Court.”
Trucksafe
+1

As a result: the rule is on hold. States can resume issuing/renewing non‑domiciled CDLs under the prior standard unless they voluntarily adopt the new one.
FreightWaves
+1

Why This Matters (Much More Than Just Paperwork)

For drivers, carriers, owner‑operators, this isn’t just a legal footnote — it’s a potential industry shift with real consequences.

Driver Supply & Rates – The rule aimed at shrinking the pool of eligible new truck drivers (via non‑domiciled CDLs) would act like a “capacity brake” on trucking. Fewer eligible drivers = fewer trucks = potential upward pressure on freight rates. Some analysts viewed this as a tactic to pull the market out of a multi‑year freight‑recession.
DC Velocity
+1

Carriers’ Workforce Strategy – Many fleets rely on non‑domiciled CDL holders (immigrant workers, out‑of‑state applicants). The pause means those hiring plans have fewer shocks for now. But the ambiguity also means planning risk is elevated.
Licensing & State Agencies – State driver licensing agencies were facing a new rule mid‑stream; now they’re in limbo. Compliance policies, documentation processes all face uncertainty.
Driver Safety &

Integrity Narrative – Proponents say this is about ensuring only qualified drivers with verifiable histories apply. Opponents say the evidence linking domicile status to safety is thin.
Trucksafe
+1

Multiple Perspectives: What You Won’t Always Hear

Mainstream view – The rule was a bold move by the White House & FMCSA to crack down on perceived “loopholes” in CDL issuance.
DC Velocity

Carrier/Driver voice – Many smaller carriers and drivers fear the rule would crowd out value by reducing available drivers, increasing costs, and complicating hiring.
Advocacy/Opposition angle – Groups like the Owner‑Operator Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA) supported the crackdown on non‑domiciled CDLs, citing safety & fairness.
DC Velocity
On the flip side: plaintiffs argue the rule unfairly bars legal workers (asylum seekers, DACA recipients) and lacks strong safety data.
FreightWaves
+1

Unheard side – The rule may have unintended ripple effects: logistic bottlenecks, increased driver fatigue (if fewer drivers), potential uptick in informal/undocumented driving. Also: impact on families and communities who rely on these jobs.

Industry Response & What’s Next

The industry is reacting with caution. Analysts say the pause delays any immediate capacity tightening. For example: TD Cowen noted the ambiguity hurts carriers’ forecasting for 2026‑27.
DC Velocity
+1

Legal timeline: The case is winding through the D.C. Circuit. The court will decide whether to grant a full stay and then ultimately rule on the merits. The rule might be implemented, revised or scrapped depending on outcome.
Trucksafe

Carriers and drivers should keep their eyes open for:

Whether states adopt the rule voluntarily despite the stay

Whether the rule is modified (scope narrowed)

The timing of the court’s final decision — which could trigger a rapid shift

Bottom Line – Driving Forward in Uncertain Terrain

For you behind the wheel or running a small fleet: here are the takeaway points:

The rule that could have capped many new CDLs is on hold — for now.

Planning remains shaky: driver supply assumptions may still change quickly.

If you hire drivers who rely on non‑domiciled CDLs, you’ll want to watch your state’s licensure stance.

If you’re a driver aiming for a CDL, at least the path isn’t changing today — but it might later.

In short: stay alert, stay informed, and don’t assume things will remain stable. Build flexibility into your driver‑strategy, gear up for regulatory shifts, and don’t get caught off‑guard.

👉 Want to dig deeper? Subscribe to daily updates on trucking regulation and strategy at LifeAsATrucker.com

👉 Looking for how to earn while you’re parked or manage off‑duty income? Check out OffDutyMoney.com